Wondering how you could earn $25 by just signing up? Earn $25 for free by joining Payoneer.
Angdee - Rubbish
How about finishing game of thrones instead
Aoberes8 - GOT is the GOAT
Love GRRM books
3alyafff - Amazing
I love his writing :’) so beautiful
ThatGuy1966 - A great addition to the series we’ve come to love so much!
A fantastic read. I loved every page.
OU_Goof - 700 pages of nonsense
I love Game of Thrones. This book took me nearly a year to finish. The first 100-150 pages are decent, about Aegon the Conquerer, and gives decent back story regarding things in the series. The rest is written like a giant run-on sentence with characters who don’t matter and have names so similar, that even if they did matter, you can’t keep them straight.
I gave this two stars and I’m not mad that I read it, but this could have been much better.
Martell_Mania - Meh
Tries to create a Silmarillion-like mythos. Fails. Doesn’t even broach the days leading to Robert’s Rebellion. Only successfully points out that Targaryen’s are fickle, freakish, incestous weirdos-whose only real power comes from the fact that for a time, they have a bigger gun.
Northernettle - Just and endless list of names with gruwsome deaths
Nothing in this list sparks interest. Grrm is well known for finding intricate ways of getting rid of one’s competitors. In this book he forgot to build affection between the reader and the character to be killed before the stroke lands. Seems like an endless list of meaningless deaths.
david haight - A fantasy that’s welcome ,hbo are you paying attention?
What’s there to say that hasn’t been said already. I just hope hbo does this “prequel” justice unlike the massacre that was the final season of g.o.t. , the Targaryen bloodline is fascinating and the clever politics that are displayed in martins writings hold a parallel to any modern societal family in power,wether that be politics,entertainment,economically powerful groups.
I like millions of others ,I will cherish the fantasy world that Martin has created...a little of us can relate and even see characteristics of ourselves in every character. This is an excellent tale that breaks the monotony of our robotic society. I just wish I had a fantasy time machine to see it all unfold. Thank you George for giving me over a decade of enjoyment.
Bonaiglan - Not a shining literary moment
Could not Finnish this book... So dry and uninspired, just the facts. Flat disappointing.
hunterj7 - Boring
Don’t waste your money or time. Book is boring. I
stopped half way through to read the reviews and see if I was missing something. I wasn’t it’s just lame.
Nuatatud - Fire and Blood.
Huge disappointment! This book reads like the book of Numbers in the Bible. Endless trail of names and mayhaps, unrelated rabbit holes. It is a maddening mess with only brief interludes of coherent consistent story line.
MusicFiend333 - Long...
Very long and dry. A book presented more like a long list of characters than a story. Reminiscent of the part of the Bible with all the begats lol
PatheticMiner - True Telling
As a fan of the GoT series I absolutely love this book, I realize a lot of people don’t like this because it’s written more as a history book instead of going in detail with each character. But while it doesn’t go j to as much detail with each character it still tells the beginning of Targaryen rule wonderfully. It has lore, story, twists and turns everywhere. It gets you to feel love and hatred and sympathy for characters in such a small amount of time. If you want to learn more of the history of the history behind our favorite series this is definitely a must. If you’re not into history books so much maybe just sample it and buy it if you you like it, otherwise just wait for the next book/season to come out.
Strange Highways - Great Read.
More of a history book than a novel but, was hard to put down once I got started.
Dead Carl - Disappointed
Terrible book. I was expecting an action-packed thriller, instead I got a boring, fictional history of Westeros. Admittedly I only read 100 or so pages, but it was like reading the Old Testament.
Gothamcity218 - Amazing
Way better than I expected it to be. Can’t wait for the second book!!!!!
nathansmith.org - Decent
I’ve read all of sweet George’s books. He is so talented. But have to say, why let HBO tell your story before u can?!! FIRE AND BLOOD was decent but why not finish the SONG OF ICE AND FIRE first?!!
bbsfresh - Disappointing
This book is just a history lesson written from a narrative point of view and is the worst book in the franchise
Mark Serena - Don’t bother reading
Mainly a re-packaging of what was already written in his “The World of Ice & Fire”. Very little original material.
Rudithecat - Fire and Blood
From the beginning til the end this book kept me entertained as only a prequel to the Game of Thornes could do. Reading it again to see what I missed the first reading.
TBarry300 - Fire and Blood
Interesting but not the storytelling we’re used to. This not a novel - it’s a history book
sts1987 - If you read world of ice and fire, you can skip this
The book is a little too similar at times to world of ice and fire, but did flesh out the history.
tc_sting - Lazy and useless
So if you’ve read the actual series then this book will make sense, character, landscape, and general tone wise.
That is where the good ends.
This book is lazy and unnecessary. It reads like a Wikipedia, simple, non commitment to character development, plot intrigue, nor particular social analysis. The plot is emotionally void and forgettable.
Most the elements seem to be stolen straight from Russian and English royalty history and simply re worded and renamed.
The challenge with a product like this is it is a clear cash grab and makes one wonder if the author ever really wrote the actual series or did he stumble across novels of someone else’s work and simply stole that too.
As a popular line says: shame. Shame. Shame.
ErinBobaron - Fire and Blood
Intriguing, but character development falls short of what I’ve come to expect from Martin. I would have rather read Winds of Winter.
cherylsgoodies - Fire and Blood-but no MEAT
I LOVE the original series of books, but this seems a non-fleshed out history book. It just retells what happened. While you may get why people do what they do, it’s in a basic sense- not the fully realized and emoted way the original series paints landscapes of lives. It’s just kind of FLAT. You know who is flying which dragon where, and a very basic why - but not the feelings involved. Feels like he gave this to the fans because he had to give them SOMETHING.
Artinobil - Horrible time waster
GRRM can’t finish the real saga he started, unlike true hall of fame fantasy writers like E Howard and Tolkien. He should step aside and let a professional like Sanderson finish it, GRRM just doesn’t want to admit he is a hack who can’t finish. His inability to write is threatening to destroy his legacy.
zordacme - Waste of time
Doubt if George Martin contributed much. Just a chronology of what happened before game of thrones. Doesn’t even get up to start of thrones saga. No reason to care about any character in the book. Don’t bother
WestCoastIsBestCoast - Oof...this hurts.
If you’re already into the books AND you are ASoIaF completist, you’ll most likely find some joy in reading this book. If you’re just a book reader who is into the main series and not all the tertiary short stories and novellas, I suggest checking it out in a library or B&N before buying. It is dry. Very dry. “The World of Ice and Fire” is more interesting. Wish this was Winds, and I understand the mob of readers with pitchforks in their hands about yet another book that isn’t advancing the core story. The hate George gets about not publishing Winds on time is counterproductive; does he owe us the story? How would you like to see fans of your work turn on you? If you didn’t need to write another sentence again and could retire comfortably, you might consider giving the people who think you’re their puppet the finger. Best to keep the moaning to a low grumble.
reviewer number two - Disappointing
There is no story or character development. It could have been interesting, but if I’m going to read an extended appendix it might as well be from LOTR.
Blackbellabelle - HUGE ASIOAF FAN, BUT THIS BOOK WAS A COMPLETE WASTE OF TIME!
At no point did I feel drawn in to this book... For a fake-history book, It goes into excruciating detail on ridiculous things like; a character’s facial expression, design of boat/castle, and character’s personality. This book felt like fan fiction cloaked in history. In fact, it was painfully obvious that this book was written over years compiled of material patched together by GRRM. The narrator would digress mid paragraph and begin his 10-page explanation of something not related to the current story, leaving the reader thinking they may have accidentally flipped ahead. There were times I thought I was reading fan fiction from Elio and Linda. I would have been happier reading the U.S. Tax Code, than wasting time with GRRM’s desperate attempt to still be considered an author. Go pick up a Bible and leave this book where it be.
Flint1204 - Mostly another rip-off
Don’t buy this book. Find a way to get it some other way. Half of the content is already published in other novellas. The rest is uninspired. If you don’t read it you’re not missing much.
GEORGE HOW MUCH MONEY DO YOU HAVE TO MAKE? You have no kids. You’re a bajillionaire allready.
Finish the [email protected]@@ series. Or let someone else write it for you. OR JUST BE HONEST with the folks who made you a bajillionaire allready, and admit what you’ve known for years now: you have no intention of finishing. Because it would shut off the TV money.
I’m not buying another GRRM product.
Switzerland_Jade - It’s a nice read, but...
Winds of Winter would be better, but beggers can’t be choosers.
Bookreader225 - Loved it.
Can’t wait to read the next one.
JHACO1235 - History Book
Brilliant, brilliant book. Written as a history book. If you don’t like books like the nature of Alexander by Mary Renault, you will not like this one. Wealth of information in this tome. Wish he had not cut it off for a second volume. Author is rather sadistic in that sense. The book is dense, I can’t believe he wrote this. I understand why it would take him so long. Sad I’ll have to wait forever for the second volume.
dfzlzx - C t. !
lilsatanzking - Porn
HeathenCC - Scholarly
I cannot say whether this was either a good or bad book. The writing was dry, but some of the content was interesting. It would have been better served by a narrator familiar to readers. Perhaps the last living Westeros Dragon would have added some sort of actual personality to the history, or some sense of accuracy. Unreliable narrator is not only a literary term in the case of this supposed history. I kept waiting for some sort of culmination of events- only to find myself dangling into the abyss of another cliffhanger. Disappointing. I cannot find it in myself to castigate a man who has his very own battle to plot, if with pen and not sword.
DCulver01 - The most boring fantasy historical ever
I’ve read all of the other books through twice, and of course, I watch the show. So I really was looking forward to reading a prequel that explained the beginnings of all things GoT.
This is not that.
It’s the most boring, repetitive, completely arbitrary bunch of gobbledygook that’s ever been marketed. If Apple truly cared about its faithful readers, it would issue refunds automatically to anyone duped into buying this.
ApN843 - I can’t wait to get started
Pyklodeon - Book 1 of 2?
Maybe I’ll wait to see if he finishes this series before I buy another one of his books.
864678346 - Dear Haters
Wow- hold your criticism about another supplementary volume. How about you write a tens of thousands of page long saga? Support for GRRM and ASOIAF material in any form. Plus I really do want to know what happens in current day Valyria.
Padpadpad momma - YAY GEORGE!!
I myself look forward to learning more about the house of dragons. There isn’t enough in the series! Bring it on~ preordered!
More crap thieves - FINISH YOUR SCHEDULED BOOKS
Anyone else getting really annoyed by all these ancillary releases and NO WOW after SEVEN years..? I am
walker_boh - Hold off
It says it’s one of two...we have no indication Martin will ever finish this series. I would wait until the ENTIRE series is out so you don’t get sucked in. Could be 20 years before we ever see the second volume :)
mcmayfire - Great Wonderful Tales
It’s gunna be it’s own book I hope i gets shown on HBO as a Series if it’s own kind
I like cookies!!!!! - WOW
We need the Winds of Winter, not this... Excellent book none the less, Apple is awful...
Enjoy high maximum transfers into more than 120 currencies while saving up to 90% over local banks! The cheap, fast way to send money abroad.
Free transfer up to 500 USD!
PapaZeek - Fun for GoT diehards but feels incomplete
Reads like a history text not a novel, as intended by author. The biblical “begats” are even more abundant than in the novels. Ends rather suddenly, not even in a “to be continued” sort of manner, it just stopped. A bit dissatisfied at that, but overall I enjoyed the read. Lots of Easter eggs for those paying attention, but the book is only for diehard GoT nerds (me), casual readers can safely skip.
FARA old age - ع
فيبتعد خخطصصطعع از تو تهوةنربل
Mind Lab Pro 🎯
Mind Lab Pro boosts work performance and productivity with nootropics for focus, multitasking under stress, creative problem-solving and more.